Waking up to a good laugh is always welcome. Prosecutor Håkan Roswall, who Ankata described as a being a clown. Brokep told world press at the press conference two days ago that Mr Roswall can’t count and hasn’t finished fifth grade.
Well in a series of moves that earned the comment “EPIC WINNING LOL” by Brokep on #spectrial on Twitter, Mr Roswall first reduced the charges from, and I’m not sure I can translate this properly, “accessory to manufacturing” to “accessory to publishing”. This is barely more than what Jammie Thomas was dragged to court over. Prosecutor Roswall now has to prove that its illegal to make something available for manufacturing when no manufacturing has occurred.
But it wouldn’t be the Roswall we’ve come to known if he managed to hold on the ball from there. Oh no:
Defense: “How can you tell that this tracker.prq.to is the Pirate Bay tracker?
Prosecutor: “You can’t” <- huh?
D: “So the prosecutor claims that the software always uses The Pirate Bay, provided that it’s his claim that the software uses The Pirate Bay? What happens if the torrent contains multiple trackers?”
P: “It doesn’t.”
D: “Can the Prosecutor produce a copy of the torrent-files so that the court may verify this?”
P: <digresses into the details on how the research was conducted>
D: “Why doesn’t the Prosecutor have copies of these files?”
Seriously? “It doesn’t”? Keep in mind that this Sweden’s TOP IT-prosecutor! Most torrents contain multiple trackers, we know that, the defense knows that and I’m pretty sure the prosecution knows that as well. And why are there no copies of the torrents?
Then again this is the same prosecutor that can’t operate Power Point. In what is the most important case in his career he was told yesterday that he should “stop wasting the courts time and proceed with pen and paper”. This after spending 15 minutes battling his laptop.
That all you say? Why of course not! Earlier today(sv):
[10.04] Fredrik Neij requests to make a comment on the analysis of the trackers. This is normally not allowed but the court makes an exception.
Fredrik Neij explains that the torrent-files being shown contains no information and that they merely passed through The Pirate Bays servers
“The prosecution is building a case on a misunderstanding of the technology.” – defendant Fredrik Neij.
The court requests him to clarify and asks: “Are you claiming that the evidence before us doesn’t prove that the Pirate Bays’ trackers where used?”
The defendants are pleased when they all answer yes.
[10.07] Prosecutor Håkan Roswall requests a 10 minute recess.
I’m a bit divided here though, I mean were it not for the prosecutor acting as the shit shield for the MPAA and IFPI I probably wouldn’t mind the case being thrown out on a technicalty. I lends even more weight to the fact that these companies don’t understand what they’re doing. Since either way, no matter the outcome, either in this court or the ones that will follow, all its doing is stalling for time for society to decide if we want a free internet or if will let the content industry restart it as a cable tv network.
Great write up! I’m retweeting!
[...] the purpleflagship blog, which is basing its claims on the swedish audio feed, I think: [10.04] Fredrik Neij requests to [...]
Solid blog. I got a lot of good data. I?ve been keeping an eye on this technology for awhile. It?s interesting how it keeps varying, yet some of the core components remain the same. Have you seen much change since Google made their latest acquisition in the field?
Maybe someone can clarify something for me. I’m just not getting it!
I’d just like to let you know how much I learnt from reading blog Liked you.Hope 2 be back soon for some more goodies
Hello!
Is it Okay if I ask something kinda off matter? I’m wanting to view this page on my new iPad but it won’t show up appropriately, do you may have any alternatives? Should I attempt and locate an update for my software package or something? Thanks upfront! Jennine x
Usually I don’t article on blogs, but I desire to say that this article really forced me to try and do so! Thanks, quite nice article.
I agree with much of what peoples comments are that I am reading here.
HipokizoPkica Football ennimiheki Watch NFL Football Online miccBeerofz Akvazrukk aaaDYNqD
Came across your website through Digg. I’ll be joining to your feed.
Nikbaczinezz Stamford Connecticut eremymany High Interest BrenbonFikkman moceccukkoway Breanneozikko
good post, added you to my RSS reader.
Pretty very good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have quite enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing for the feed and I hope you article once more soon.
Bookmarked, I love your blog!
Hello!
Is it Okay if I ask something kinda off subject? I’m attempting to view this page on my new iPad but it will not indicate up correctly, do you have any remedies? Need to I try and locate an update for my application or something? Thanks upfront! Jennine x
zawannameeker Stamford Jobs oecphkimenz High Interest monzybekken kanPapakeo zhabOpcahk
I’m getting a javascript error, is anyone else?
Hi!
Is it Okay if I ask something kinda off topic? I’m looking to view this page on my new iPad but it surely will not indicate up effectively, do you have any answers? Really should I try and find an update for my software package or something? Thanks upfront! Jennine x
Many thanks for the wonderful site and also advice..
Aw, this was a really quality blog post. In theory I’d like to write like this too – taking time and real effort to make a fantastic article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and never seem to get something done.